Loading...
Loading Live Scoring...
*All times CAT (GMT+2)

Rugby | Springboks

Watercooler chat: Scotland v SA



Heyneke Meyer announced his Springbok side to take on Scotland this afternoon. Juan de Jongh and Guthro Steenkamp come into the side for Jaco Taute and Beast Mtwarira.

Share your thoughts on the team with us and we will aim to answer all your questions, share your opinions and give you all the relevant information.

Our senior correspondent Gavin Rich has joined up with the Boks on tour and will be attending today's press conference. We'll get him to share from there.

In the office the team will be made up of senior correspondent Brenden Nel, site editor Johan Coetzee and content producer Thando Mxoli.

To interact with us, make use of the Facebook comments section below this article or get us on Twitter making use of the hashtag #sswatercooler.

As we did last week, we asked the team members to get the ball rolling and give us the changes they would make to last week's Bok team. Here is what the gave us:

Brenden Nel (@brendennel): Changes to the lineup – mmm. Mine would be: Taute to fullback, Juan in at centre (although think I had it that way last week) and Mvovo on the wing in Hougaard’s place. Up front Gurthro in for CJ.

Thando Mxoli (@thando82): I would drop Zane as I believe he was poor on attack, his kicking was anything but special. Francois Hougaard would also be dropped and replaced by Lwazi Mvovo as I believe Francois was poor on defence and his workrate was poor, which contributed to him seeing very little of the ball.

Jaco would move to fullback and I believe Juan de Jongh has done enough to be given a chance at the position he has played his best rugby in this year.

Guthro comes in for Beast, he has the experience, has been playing great rugby for Toulose and he definitely won’t let the side down in terms of work rate both on defence and attack. I understand the need for continuity but I feel if there is a match where Heyneke can make changes it is this one, hence I would give Adriaan a rest and give Chiliboy a run this weekend. With Chiliboy in the team, the scrum won't be weakened as he has played with both Jannie and Guthro. He will be eager and I doubt he would weaken the side either on attack and defence.

Johan Coetzee (@jwcoetzee): Up front we obviously need a replacement for Beast. Guthro is fit by all accounts, so no need to fiddle there. Also happy with Heinke's impact off the bench last week, so he can stay there.

At scrumhalf I'd like to see Hougaard start ahead of Pienaar, if only for this match. Give him strict orders not to box-kick (so avoiding breaking down his confidence with more charge-downs) and let him explore what he is capable of under the new laws (especially the five-second rule, which could bring his instinctive, opportunistic self to the fore)

Lastly, De Jongh in for De Villiers with Juandre Kruger taking over the captaincy. I wouldn't mind it too much if this move was permamnent (at least until Jean can find his old spark again).

Well, there you have it. Agree, disagree? And was Heyneke too conservative? Let us have it.

Shop

The Poisoned Chalice
The Springboks have had several post-isolation coaches, and if they agree on nothing else, they will concur that everyone in the job suffers enormous pressure
R157.00
Coach - Marco Botha
At 34, Heyneke Meyer was fired as head coach of a Super Rugby team for the second time
R114.00
South Africa XV Ball
South Africa XV Ball Now: R119 Was: R200 Format:Sport EquipmentProduct type:SportDelivery:Dispatched within 24 hours (1 working day) This fan ball...
R119.00


Comments

More expert analysis and opinion from Sport24
The opinions expressed by Sport24 experts and bloggers are theirs alone, and do not necessarily represent those of SuperSport

Event Streaming

Channel Streaming

Other Live Streaming

Event Streaming

Channel Streaming

Sports Talk



Kyle Brown
Fans, fun and Sevens success
The week leading up to the Nelson Mandela Bay Sevens was a special one. The fans were passionate,...

Brendan Venter
Boks must think outside the box
Springbok supporters have every right to feel disenchanted after an underwhelming end-of-year tour.

Tony Johnson
Boks and Wallabies burnt in final outings
Playing the last test of the year in the last week of November has again proven to be a stumbling...

Gavin Rich
Boks learned quite a lot actually
When SuperSport returned from the Millennium Stadium to the studio discussion, it was mentioned...