Football | Germany

Dortmund fans © Action Images

German fans angered by face-scan plan



Football fans in one German state may have to pass through "face scanners" at stadiums, according to interior ministry proposals designed to eradicate hooliganism.

The proposals, which entail comparing visitors' biometric data to a database of known football rioters, have been denounced as Orwellian by one national fan association.

But the interior minister of the former east German state of Mecklenburg-Vorpommern, Lorenz Caffier, said current measures to prevent hooligans from slipping past security in stadiums, such as match bans, were not working.

"Along with the help of personalised entrance tickets and face scanners, notorious rioters can be effectively kept out of the stadiums," said Caffier in a statement.

"We have to go beyond the current discussions," he said.

A study has been commissioned to determine the practical and legal feasibility of using the technology in stadiums, after which a pilot run of the scanners will be carried out.

In a country that has had a difficult relationship with surveillance in the past, any form of monitoring the population is met with suspicion.

"This idea is a disgrace to democracy and is reminiscent of Orwell's 1984," said Philipp Markhardt, spokesman for the national Pro-Fans association.

"The attempt to combat a problem with surveillance rather than attacking the root of the issue is out of touch with reality and, above all, is a drastic invasion of the civil liberties of individual fans," he said.

Facial recognition technology has already been tried out in countries, such as Poland and Brazil, to try to eradicate a violent minority of fans from gaining entrance to matches.

Shop

FIFA 12 (PS3)
FIFA 12 brings to the pitch the game-changing new Player Impact Engine, a physics engine built to deliver real-world physicality in every interaction on the pitch
R478.95
Red: My autobiography
No player has been more synonymous with the glory years of Manchester United Football Club over the past two decades than right-back Gary Neville.
R221.95
David Beckham: My side
He may live in Madrid but he continues to make front-page headlines
R125.95
The Professor: Arsene Wenger
Idealistic, passionate and scientific, Arsene Wenger led the modernisation of English football
R139.95


Comments

More expert analysis and opinion from Sport24
The opinions expressed by Sport24 experts and bloggers are theirs alone, and do not necessarily represent those of SuperSport
More expert analysis and opinion from Sport24
The opinions expressed by Sport24 experts and bloggers are theirs alone, and do not necessarily represent those of SuperSport

Live Video Streaming

Sports Talk



Rowen Fernandez
A Tshwane derby in Soweto
This week is all about the cup final – the Nedbank Cup final to be exact.

Collins Okinyo
Can Harambee Stars repeat Tunisia 2004?
The African Cup of Nations 2013 and World Cup 2014 qualifiers are in the offing and the question...

Carol Radull
Where is the money?
It’s no secret that football clubs in Africa and particularly in the Kenyan Premier League suffer...

Calvin Emeka Onwuka
Chelsea – best team in Europe?
Uefa and all their marketing and communications people do their best to try and portray the Uefa...

Brenden Nel
A city in mourning
The streets of Munich are empty this morning as a city in mourning comes to terms with its loss.

Azwihangwisi Mukhuba
The race is not to the swift
Not many people could have predicted it but the final minutes of the final day of the Barclays...