Googlies and politicians
by Neil Manthorp 25/10/2004, 12:28
When Gerald Majola took over as chief executive of the United Cricket Board he didn't expect to have an easy ride and he certainly didn't expect much sympathy from people when the going got tough. But like it or not he has all my sympathy this week.
He will almost certainly spend the next seven days - if not longer -
dealing with the fallout of a meeting he held with politicians and
government officials who have almost no idea of the intricacies of cricket
and, frankly, don't care. And neither should they.
The trouble with politicians is that they can be intimidating to us
'normal' people and they usually get what they want when they're dealing
with non-politicians. Basically, we tell them what they want to hear and we
lose the argument. That's why they are politicians and we are not.
So when Majola presented cricket's case to the portfolio committee on
sport in parliament on Friday and was tackled head-on about the colour
problem in national teams, he was bullied into giving assurances that he had
no right to give.
Saturday's newspapers quoted Majola at length guaranteeing the
politicians that there would definitely be five black cricketers in the
squad to tour India and that Mark Boucher would be dropped in favour of
Thami Tsolekile. Oh dear.
The chief executive is not a selector, of course, and has no right to
make such demands. But that is the least of Majola's worries.
If Boucher's name does not appear when the squad is announced on
Wednesday morning he will have every right to query his non-selection on
grounds of race and demand compensation. Yet another legal battle (he has
lost all five he's been in so far) will not please the chief executive but
even that isn't his biggest worry.
As an affiliate member of the ICC, Cricket South Africa is bound by the
constitution of the world ruling body and therefore a) cannot allow
governmental interference or influence in the control and running of cricket
in South Africa and b) cannot allow any player to be prejudiced on grounds
of race, creed or religion.
No wonder Majola was quoted all over the Sunday newspapers breaking
land-speed records for back-peddling. No, he didn't say there would
definitely be five black players. No, he didn't say Boucher would be dropped
etc etc. Unfortunately, at least one member of the committee is quite clear
about what he remembers Majola saying:
"Gerald Majola said there would be five black players in the squad. He
said their succession plan was beginning to yield results and they would
demonstrate this by including five players in the squad to tour India," said
Butana Komphela on Monday.
Oh dear.
Now for the good news - yes, there is some! Cricket doesn't have to
select any obscure, largely unheard-of players to appease the politicians
and the withdrawal of Nicky Boje means that Boucher can still be selected
and there can still be SIX black players in the squad, all selected on
merit. But it was a close call for the chief executive. Next time he talks
to politicians he'd better learn to speak their language.
Possible squad: Graeme Smith (captain), Boeta Dippenaar, Jacques
Rudolph, Jacques Kallis, Martin van Jaarsveld, Hashim Amla, Andrew Hall,
Shaun Pollock, Mark Boucher, Justin Ontong, Robin Peterson, Garnett Kruger,
Makhaya Ntini, Charl Langeveldt.